One set costs about as much as a pizza and gives you more than half a liter of paint. The other charges that much for three or four small tubes. Put that way, the HIMI gouache vs Winsor and Newton decision sounds obvious, yet plenty of painters own both, because the two products solve different problems. HIMI is a budget, student-grade jelly cup gouache built for volume and practice; Winsor & Newton Designers Gouache is a professional tube line with published pigment and permanence information, built for finished work.
Quick answer: Choose HIMI if you want inexpensive, generous, opaque paint for learning, sketchbooks and illustrations you will scan. Choose Winsor & Newton Designers Gouache if you need documented pigments, permanence ratings and smoother, finer handling for originals you plan to sell or display. HIMI costs a few cents per ml; Winsor & Newton typically costs many times more per ml, depending on color series.
This comparison breaks down formula, handling, color information, permanence, price and format, then gives a verdict by use case. If you are already leaning toward the budget option and want to pick a specific set, the HIMI jelly cup gouache review walks through each set size.
The Two Brands in Brief
HIMI (MIYA HIMI)
HIMI is a Chinese art-supply brand whose gouache is sold mainly in sets of 30 ml jelly cups housed in a plastic carrying case, commonly in 18, 24 and 56 colors. It is positioned as student or hobby paint. Most sets do not list pigment index codes or lightfastness ratings. For more on origin and pricing, see where HIMI gouache is made.
Winsor & Newton Designers Gouache
Winsor & Newton is a long-established British art-materials brand founded in London in the 1830s. Its Designers Gouache is one of the most widely available professional gouache lines in the US, sold primarily in 14 ml tubes across a large range of colors, with colors grouped into price series. The brand publishes pigment information and a permanence rating for each color, which is the main reason professionals choose it.
HIMI Gouache vs Winsor and Newton: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | HIMI jelly cup gouache | Winsor & Newton Designers Gouache |
|---|---|---|
| Grade | Student / hobby | Professional / artist |
| Format | 30 ml cups in a carrying case | 14 ml tubes (sets and single tubes) |
| Typical consistency | Thick paste, needs thinning | Creamy, smoother out of the tube |
| Pigment disclosure | Usually not listed | Pigment information published per color |
| Permanence rating | Generally not stated | Rated per color using the brand’s permanence system |
| Opacity | High, aided by filler | High on most colors; some colors are intentionally less opaque |
| Rewettable when dry | Yes | Yes |
| Color range | Fixed set palettes | Large open-stock range, buy individual colors |
| Approximate cost per ml | A few cents | Roughly 50 cents to over $1 depending on series |
| Single-color replacement | Limited; some sellers offer refill cups | Easy; any color sold individually |
| Best for | Practice, sketchbooks, classes, scanned art | Originals, commissions, display pieces |
Formula and Pigment Load
Both are traditional gouache: pigment in a water-soluble binder, typically gum arabic, with enough pigment and extender to make an opaque, matte film. The difference lies in proportion and pigment selection.
Professional gouache lines generally aim for a high pigment concentration and often use single pigments for many colors, so a blue is one specific blue pigment rather than a mixture. That makes color mixing more predictable: two single-pigment colors mix cleanly, while mixing two blended colors can quickly involve four or five pigments and turn dull.
Student gouache, HIMI included, tends to rely more on extenders such as chalk-like white fillers to build opacity at a lower cost. This is not a defect; it is a design choice that keeps a 30 ml cup affordable. The visible effect is that HIMI mixes can drift toward pastel or chalky more quickly, especially when white is added.
Handling and Texture
Handling is where many painters notice the difference first.
- Out of the container: HIMI is thick and paste-like; you will almost always add water. Winsor & Newton tubes are generally creamier and closer to ready to use, needing less water for flat fills.
- Flat fills: Both can produce flat, matte areas. With HIMI, consistency control matters more; underthinned paint streaks or cracks, overthinned paint loses opacity. Professional tubes tend to be more forgiving across a range of dilutions.
- Re-wetting: Both lift when rewetted. This is normal gouache behavior. Light, single strokes over dry layers keep either brand clean.
- Drying on the palette: Both can be reactivated with water after drying. HIMI’s thick cup paint dries in the cup if lids are left open; tubes resist drying until opened and squeezed.
Color Information and Mixing
The single largest practical gap is information. Winsor & Newton prints or publishes pigment details for each color. When you see a pigment code such as PB15 (phthalocyanine blue) or PR122 (quinacridone magenta), you know how it will mix, roughly how it will behave in light and how it compares with the same pigment in other brands.
Most HIMI sets offer names only. You can still mix beautifully with them, but you learn the colors by swatching rather than by reading. For a painter who mixes from a limited palette, that difference can matter more than the price.
A practical mixing test
If you own both or are deciding, try this simple exercise: mix a green from each brand’s yellow and blue, and a purple from each red and blue. Single-pigment professional colors tend to produce cleaner secondaries; blended student colors can be livelier in some mixes and duller in others. The test tells you more about your own palette than any spec sheet.
Permanence and Lightfastness
Winsor & Newton rates the permanence of each Designers Gouache color. The line includes many durable colors and a handful of brilliant colors that are less permanent, and the ratings let you avoid those for pieces meant to last. Like many gouache lines, some of the most vivid pinks and violets are prized for design and reproduction work rather than long-term display.
HIMI generally does not publish lightfastness ratings. That does not mean every color fades, but it does mean you must test colors yourself if longevity matters. A simple window test of a few weeks with half of each swatch covered will show which colors shift.
For illustration that will be scanned or photographed, permanence is less important. For originals hung on a wall or sold, it becomes the deciding factor.
Price and Value
Price is HIMI’s strongest argument. A 24-color HIMI set of 30 ml cups, about 720 ml of paint, typically sells in the US for roughly $20 to $35. That is a few cents per ml.
Winsor & Newton Designers Gouache in 14 ml tubes is priced by color series, with US prices varying by retailer. Expect roughly 50 cents to over a dollar per ml. A starter set of a handful of tubes may cost about the same as a large HIMI set while containing a fraction of the paint.
| Example purchase | Approximate paint volume | What it buys you |
|---|---|---|
| HIMI 24-color set | About 720 ml | Wide color selection for months of practice |
| W&N small starter tube set | Under 100 ml | Documented pigments in a limited palette |
| W&N limited palette of single tubes | About 70 to 100 ml | A primary-based palette chosen for mixing |
Value depends on what you are paying for: volume and variety, or information and permanence.
Format: Cups vs Tubes
Advantages of jelly cups
- Every color visible and accessible at once.
- Large volume per color; you rarely run out mid-painting.
- Case doubles as storage and partial mixing area.
Disadvantages of jelly cups
- Cups can dry if lids are not snapped closed.
- Bulky to carry compared with a few tubes.
- Risk of contamination if brushes go directly into the cup.
Advantages of tubes
- Paint stays fresh longer in a sealed tube.
- Easy to build a custom palette one color at a time.
- Compact for travel kits.
Disadvantages of tubes
- Small volume; whites and frequently used colors run out quickly.
- Caps can stick, and paint dried in the neck can be wasted.
Where Arteza Fits In
People comparing these two often also look at Arteza vs Winsor and Newton gouache. Arteza is a US-based brand selling budget tube gouache sets, commonly in small tubes of around 12 ml, manufactured overseas. It sits between the two in format: student-grade paint like HIMI, but in a tube format like Winsor & Newton. Its appeal is low-cost tubes; like most budget lines, pigment and lightfastness information is more limited than in professional ranges. If you prefer tubes but are not ready to pay professional prices, it is a format alternative worth knowing about, though the same “practice versus permanence” logic applies.
Verdict by Use Case
| Your situation | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Learning gouache from scratch | HIMI | Volume allows free practice without worrying about waste |
| Daily sketchbook and journaling | HIMI | Bright, opaque, inexpensive per page |
| Illustration for scanning and print | Either; HIMI for budget | Permanence matters less for digital deliverables |
| Selling original paintings | Winsor & Newton | Published permanence ratings let you avoid fugitive colors |
| Limited-palette color mixing study | Winsor & Newton | Single-pigment colors mix more predictably |
| Classroom or group workshops | HIMI | Low cost per participant, sturdy case |
| Plein air with a small kit | Winsor & Newton | A few tubes pack smaller than a cup case |
| Large flat background areas | HIMI, or W&N for archival work | HIMI’s volume helps on big fills |
A Sensible Hybrid Approach
Many painters do not choose one brand exclusively. A common setup is to use HIMI for studies, practice and color experiments, then buy a few professional tubes for the colors that matter most in finished work, such as a reliable white, a primary blue, a warm yellow and a cool red. Because both are traditional, rewettable gouache, they can be used together in one painting, though matching textures takes a little attention to dilution.
If you go this route, use HIMI for underlayers and big fills, and save the professional tubes for focal points and final highlights. That stretches the expensive paint and puts the documented pigments where viewers look most.
Whichever path you take, working technique is the same. Our guide on how to use HIMI gouache paint covers consistency, layering and fixing cracks, and those principles apply to tube gouache as well.
Common Mistakes When Comparing the Two
- Comparing per set price instead of per ml. Tube sets look comparable until you account for volume.
- Judging HIMI straight from the cup. Unthinned HIMI looks streaky and cracks; thinned properly, results are much better.
- Assuming professional means every color is permanent. Even professional lines include less permanent colors; read the ratings.
- Assuming budget means every color fades. Without data you do not know; test the colors that matter to you.
FAQs
Is HIMI gouache as good as Winsor & Newton?
Not in the same way. HIMI offers strong opacity and great value for practice, but Winsor & Newton offers published pigment information, permanence ratings and generally smoother handling suited to finished work.
Can I mix HIMI and Winsor & Newton gouache?
Yes. Both are traditional water-based gouache that rewet when dry, so they can be mixed or layered in the same painting. Adjust dilution so their textures match.
Why is Winsor & Newton gouache so expensive?
Higher pigment loads, more costly pigments in some colors, single-pigment formulations, permanence testing and smaller tube volumes all raise the price per ml.
Is HIMI gouache good for professional illustration?
It can be for work that is scanned or reproduced digitally, where the physical original’s permanence is less critical. For originals sold or displayed, documented lightfastness is the safer choice.
Is Arteza gouache better than HIMI?
They are both budget lines in different formats. Arteza comes in small tubes, HIMI in large cups. The choice is mostly about format preference and price per ml rather than a clear quality gap.
Which should a beginner buy first?
Most beginners get more learning per dollar from HIMI’s large volume. Moving to professional tubes later makes sense once you know which colors you rely on.
Next Step
If the budget route fits how you paint, the next decision is which HIMI set to choose. Our in-depth look at whether the HIMI jelly cup sets are worth the money compares the 18, 24 and 56 color options so you can buy the one that matches your palette and space.



