PaintingProGuide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Crayola washable vs Melissa & Doug paint is really a question about how your kids paint. Both are washable, kid-friendly paints aimed at preschool and early elementary ages, and both dry to a matte finish on paper. Where they split is format: Crayola’s popular project paint comes in small 2 oz bottles with more colors, while Melissa & Doug’s poster paint comes in big 8 oz squeeze bottles in four primary-style colors.
That difference shapes everything from how much paint you get, to how much mixing kids do, to how easy the bottles are for little hands. Here is how they compare, side by side, based on what each brand lists.
Quick answer: Choose Melissa & Doug Washable Poster Paint if you want a lot of paint for big, messy sessions and you like the idea of kids mixing their own colors from red, yellow, green and blue. Choose Crayola Washable Kids Paint (6 count) if you want more ready-made colors in small resealable bottles and Crayola’s stated washability from skin and most washable clothing. For classrooms that need one color in bulk, Crayola Washable Paint in a 16 oz bottle is the refill option.
Our Top Picks at a Glance
- Melissa & Doug Washable Poster Paint Set (4 x 8 oz) — Best for volume and color mixing
- Crayola Washable Kids Paint (6 x 2 oz) — Best for color variety and tidy storage
- Crayola Washable Paint, 16 oz Bottle — Best single-color refill for classrooms
| Product | Best For | Key Spec | Key Strength | Price Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Melissa & Doug Poster Paint | Big sessions, mixing practice | 4 colors, 8 fl oz each (32 fl oz total) | Squeeze bottles with flip caps | $ |
| Crayola Washable Kids Paint 6ct | Color variety, small hands | 6 bottles, 2 fl oz each (12 fl oz total) | Washable from skin and most clothing | $ |
| Crayola Washable Paint 16 oz | Classroom refills | 1 bottle, 16 fl oz | Large single-color supply | $$ |
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Crayola Washable Paint | Melissa & Doug Washable Poster Paint |
|---|---|---|
| Format | 2 fl oz bottles in a 6-count set; 16 fl oz single bottles also listed | 8 fl oz squeezable bottles with flip-cap lids |
| Colors in the set | Six bright colors; listing names shades such as teal, fuchsia and blue violet | Four: red, yellow, green, blue |
| Total paint in the set | 12 fl oz | 32 fl oz |
| Stated age | 3 and up | 3 to 8 |
| Washability claim | Washable from skin and most washable clothing | Washable poster paint |
| Finish | Matte | Matte |
| Recommended surface | Paper | Paper |
| Mixing | Smooth, creamy color that blends into more hues | Primary-style set encourages mixing |
| Storage | Resealable caps | Flip-cap lids |
How We Compared
We did not paint with either brand side by side. This comparison is based on the Amazon listing details and specifications checked in October 2026, how each paint’s format, colors and stated washability fit young children, and how widely each product is reviewed by Amazon buyers.
The points we compared:
- Washability: what each listing actually claims about skin and clothing.
- Quantity: total fluid ounces per set, since kids use a lot of paint.
- Color range: ready-made colors versus primaries for mixing.
- Bottle design: how easy the bottles are to squeeze, close and store.
- Age fit: the stated age range and how that matches typical use.
Crayola Washable Paint: Overview
Crayola’s washable paint is the familiar classroom and home choice. Its most important listing claim is specific: the project paint is washable from skin and most washable clothing. That wording matters for parents, because it sets realistic expectations; it is not a promise for every fabric.
The 6-count set uses small 2 oz bottles with resealable caps, which are easy for preschoolers to hold and help keep paint fresh between sessions. The colors lean bright and modern, with shades like teal and fuchsia that kids do not have to mix themselves.
Crayola Washable Kids Paint (6 Count) — Best for Color Variety
This is the set most families start with. Six 2 oz bottles give a ready-made rainbow, and the listing describes smooth, creamy color that blends into more hues. Resealable caps keep the paint from drying out, which matters when little bottles only get a few squeezes per session.
It is listed as safe and nontoxic for ages 3 and up, and recommended for paper. At 12 fl oz in total, it is a smaller quantity than Melissa & Doug’s set, so heavy painters will need refills sooner.
Best suited for: Preschoolers and early elementary kids who like lots of colors and paint in short sessions.
Key features:
- 6 bottles, 2 fl oz each
- Washable from skin and most washable clothing
- Resealable caps
- Nontoxic, ages 3 and up
- Matte finish on paper
Pros:
- More ready-made colors
- Small bottles suit small hands
- Clear washability claim
Cons and limitations:
- Only 12 fl oz in total
- Small bottles run out fast in groups
- Listing names more colors than the count, so check the photo for the exact set
Buying consideration: Ideal for home use. Add a large Crayola refill bottle in the color your child uses most.
Crayola Washable Paint, 16 oz Bottle — Best Classroom Refill
Crayola also sells washable paint in single 16 fl oz bottles; this listing is for orange. It is the way classrooms and busy households refill the colors that disappear first.
The listing details are minimal: washable, liquid, matte finish, bottle packaging. It does not restate age or surface guidance, so follow the same practices you use for the 6-count set.
Best suited for: Teachers, daycares and families who burn through one color quickly.
Key features:
- 16 fl oz single bottle
- Washable
- Matte finish
- Liquid paint in a bottle
Pros:
- Large quantity of one color
- Matches Crayola washable sets
- Good for refilling small bottles
Cons and limitations:
- Only one color per bottle
- Higher price tier than the 6-count set
- Listing gives few details
Buying consideration: Buy refills in the colors your kids actually use up, usually primaries and white if available.
Melissa & Doug Washable Poster Paint: Overview
Melissa & Doug’s set takes the opposite approach: fewer colors, much more paint. Four 8 fl oz squeeze bottles in red, yellow, green and blue give you 32 fl oz in total, nearly three times the paint in Crayola’s 6-count set.
The squeeze bottles with flip-cap lids are quick to use; kids squeeze a puddle onto a plate and close the cap with one thumb. The four-color selection is ideal for teaching mixing: red and yellow make orange, blue and yellow make a second green, and so on.
Melissa & Doug Washable Poster Paint Set — Best for Volume and Mixing
This is the better pick for big, expressive painting: large paper on the floor, easel sessions, or several kids sharing. The listing describes four washable poster paints in 8 fl oz squeezable bottles with flip-cap lids, aimed at kids 3 to 8 for screen-free play.
Poster paint tends to be thick and opaque, which suits bold strokes on paper. The listing recommends paper as the surface and lists a matte finish. With four colors, kids can mix secondary colors themselves, which is a nice early lesson in color.
Best suited for: Families and classrooms that paint often and in large amounts, and kids learning to mix colors.
Key features:
- 4 colors: red, yellow, green, blue
- 8 fl oz (236 ml) per bottle, 32 fl oz total
- Squeezable bottles with flip-cap lids
- Ages 3 to 8
- Matte finish on paper
Pros:
- Much more paint per set
- Easy squeeze-and-flip bottles
- Encourages color mixing
Cons and limitations:
- Only four colors
- Big bottles are harder for toddlers to control
- Washability claim is less specific than Crayola’s
Buying consideration: Have paper plates or a palette ready; big squeeze bottles release more paint than kids expect.
Key Differences Explained
Washability
Both are sold as washable. Crayola’s listing goes further, stating its paint is washable from skin and most washable clothing. Melissa & Doug simply describes its paints as washable poster paint. If washability is your top concern, Crayola gives you the clearer claim, but treat both as “wash quickly” paints rather than stain-proof.
Quantity and Value
Melissa & Doug wins on volume, with 32 fl oz versus 12 fl oz in Crayola’s 6-count. Both sets sit in the same low price tier, so the Melissa & Doug set gives more paint per dollar. Crayola offers more colors per dollar.
Color Range
Crayola provides six ready-to-use bright colors. Melissa & Doug provides four core colors and leaves the rest to mixing. Younger kids who want a pink or purple right now will be happier with Crayola; kids who enjoy experimenting may prefer Melissa & Doug.
Bottles and Storage
Crayola’s small bottles with resealable caps are easy to hold and keep paint fresh. Melissa & Doug’s large squeeze bottles with flip caps are faster for adults pouring paint for a group but can be a lot for a 3-year-old to manage alone.
Age Range
Crayola lists ages 3 and up; Melissa & Doug lists 3 to 8. In practice both suit the same preschool and early elementary group.
Verdict by Use Case
- Toddler or preschooler painting at home: Crayola 6-count, for small bottles, more colors and the clearer washability claim.
- Big easel or floor painting sessions: Melissa & Doug, for the larger volume and squeeze bottles.
- Teaching color mixing: Melissa & Doug, since its four colors invite experimentation.
- Classrooms and daycares: Crayola for variety, with 16 oz Crayola refills for the colors that run out.
- Gift for a young child: either works; Crayola feels more colorful, Melissa & Doug lasts longer.
Other Washable Paints to Consider
If neither brand fits, two other washable options from our product research are worth a look. The Cra-Z-Art Washable Classic Paint 8-pack includes eight 4 oz bottles, adding white and black for more mixing options, and is listed as washable, non-toxic and made in the USA. For the very youngest painters, the EXTRIC 12-pack of washable tempera finger paints is listed for toddlers ages 1 to 3, with 12 colors in 2 oz bottles that the brand says rinse off skin, clothes and tables with soap and water.
Buying Guide: Choosing Washable Paint for Kids
Read the Washability Claim Closely
“Washable” usually means the paint is formulated to come out of skin and many fabrics with soap and water, especially when washed promptly. Look for specifics, such as Crayola’s “most washable clothing,” and always pre-treat and wash soon after painting.
Match the Bottle to the Child
Small bottles suit independent painting by preschoolers. Large squeeze bottles suit adults portioning paint for a group. Resealable or flip caps prevent spills and drying.
Choose Colors for the Goal
Ready-made colors keep young kids engaged. Primaries plus white encourage mixing and stretch your paint further.
Buy Enough Paint
Kids use far more paint than adults expect. For frequent painting or groups, prioritize total fluid ounces over color count.
How to Make Washable Paint Go Further
Whichever brand you choose, a few habits stretch every bottle. Pour small puddles onto a paper plate, muffin tin or plastic palette instead of letting kids dip brushes straight into bottles. Paint that has been contaminated with other colors in the bottle quickly turns brown, and you end up throwing it away.
Give each child a cup of water and a rag for rinsing brushes between colors. Close caps between sessions, and store bottles upright at room temperature so the paint does not separate or thicken. If paint does start to thicken, many parents stir in a small splash of water, though adding too much will thin the color and make it less opaque.
For big sessions, set out the primaries first and let kids mix secondaries on the plate. That is where the four-color Melissa & Doug set shines, but you can do the same with Crayola by holding back the extra colors until later. Mixing practice uses less paint than handing over every color at once, and it teaches kids how color actually works.
Finally, choose paper that suits thick kids’ paint. Heavier construction paper or easel paper holds poster paint without tearing or curling as much as thin printer paper, which means fewer wasted sheets and less frustration.
Kid-Friendly Painting Projects
Put either paint to work with our easy kids’ tutorials: painting a simple dinosaur uses just a few bold colors, and painted rock critters are a fun outdoor project, though rocks need acrylic or a sealer for lasting color.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming washable means stain-proof: wash clothes promptly for best results.
- Letting paint dry on fabric: dried paint is harder to remove, even washable formulas.
- Using kids’ washable paint on non-paper surfaces: both brands recommend paper; on wood or rocks it may rub off.
- Leaving caps open: paint skins over and dries in the bottle.
- Handing a toddler a big squeeze bottle: pour portions onto a plate instead.
- Buying too little paint for a group: check total ounces, not just the color count.
FAQs
Is Crayola or Melissa & Doug paint more washable?
Both are sold as washable. Crayola’s listing makes the more specific claim, washable from skin and most washable clothing, while Melissa & Doug describes its poster paint as washable. Wash promptly with either.
Which gives more paint, Crayola or Melissa & Doug?
Melissa & Doug’s 4-bottle set contains 32 fl oz in total, compared with 12 fl oz in Crayola’s 6-count set of 2 oz bottles.
Is Melissa & Doug paint good for toddlers?
It is listed for ages 3 to 8. For toddlers, an adult should portion the paint from the large squeeze bottles, since they release a lot at once.
Can I use Crayola washable paint on canvas?
Crayola recommends paper. It may work on canvas boards for practice, but for lasting results on canvas, acrylic paint is a better choice.
Does washable paint come out of clothes after it dries?
Results are best when washed quickly. Dried washable paint often still comes out with soaking and washing, but there is no guarantee on every fabric.
Which is better for a classroom, Crayola or Melissa & Doug?
Crayola offers more colors and 16 oz refill bottles, which suits classrooms. Melissa & Doug gives more total paint per set, which suits big group sessions.
Final Recommendation
There is no single winner in Crayola washable vs Melissa & Doug paint; each suits a different kind of painting. Pick the Crayola Washable Kids Paint 6-count for young kids painting at home, where color variety, small bottles and Crayola’s stated washability matter most.
Pick the Melissa & Doug Washable Poster Paint set for big sessions, shared painting and teaching color mixing, where the larger 8 oz bottles go much further. Classrooms can combine the two, using Crayola’s 16 oz washable paint as a refill for the colors that run out first.
